Pep Boys vs. Valvoline Instant Oil Change: prices compared 2026

Pep Boys is cheaper for 5 of the 5 services both chains price. The biggest gap is conventional oil change: $39.99–$54.99 at Pep Boys versus $49.99–$74.99 at Valvoline Instant Oil Change.

Prices checked

Price comparison

ServicePep BoysValvolineCheaper
Oil change
Conventional oil change$39.99–$54.99$49.99–$74.99Pep Boys by $15
Synthetic blend oil change$54.99–$74.99$64.99–$89.99Pep Boys by $12.50
High-mileage oil change$64.99–$84.99$74.99–$99.99Pep Boys by $12.50
Full synthetic oil change$74.99–$99.99$89.99–$129.99Pep Boys by $22.50
Tire rotation
Tire rotation$19.99–$29.99$19.99–$34.99Pep Boys by $2.50

Typical prices at most U.S. locations, compared at the middle of each range. Differences under 2% count as “about the same”.

How Pep Boys and Valvoline Instant Oil Change differ

Pep Boys

  • Company-run service chain owned by Icahn Automotive.
  • Stopped selling auto parts in 2024 to focus on service.
  • Full repair shop: tires, brakes, alignments, A/C and diagnostics.
  • Online booking and coupons for every location.

Discounts: online coupons, Pep Boys Rewards and fleet.

All Pep Boys prices →

Valvoline Instant Oil Change

  • You stay in your car in the bay; most oil changes take about 15 minutes.
  • Uses Valvoline oil; owned by Valvoline Inc. (the motor-oil brand is a separate company).
  • About half of locations are company-run, half franchised.
  • No appointments needed.

Discounts: app and web coupons, military and fleet.

All Valvoline Instant Oil Change prices →

Pep Boys vs. Valvoline Instant Oil Change: FAQ

Is Pep Boys cheaper than Valvoline Instant Oil Change?

Pep Boys is cheaper for 5 of the 5 services both chains price. The biggest gap is conventional oil change: $39.99–$54.99 at Pep Boys versus $49.99–$74.99 at Valvoline Instant Oil Change. Both chains set prices by market, so compare the two locations near you before you book.

Which is cheaper for an oil change, Pep Boys or Valvoline?

Pep Boys is cheaper: $74.99–$99.99 at Pep Boys versus $89.99–$129.99 at Valvoline Instant Oil Change for full synthetic oil change.

Which is cheaper for a tire rotation, Pep Boys or Valvoline?

Pep Boys is cheaper: $19.99–$29.99 at Pep Boys versus $19.99–$34.99 at Valvoline Instant Oil Change for tire rotation.

More comparisons

Firestone Complete Auto Care vs. Pep BoysJiffy Lube vs. Valvoline Instant Oil ChangeMidas vs. Pep BoysTake 5 Oil Change vs. Valvoline Instant Oil ChangeValvoline Instant Oil Change vs. Walmart