Midas vs. Pep Boys: prices compared 2026

Pep Boys is cheaper for 5 of the 8 services both chains price (3 cost about the same). The biggest gap is conventional oil change: $44.99–$64.99 at Midas versus $39.99–$54.99 at Pep Boys.

Prices checked

Price comparison

ServiceMidasPep BoysCheaper
Brake pad replacement
Brake pads, one axle$149.99–$299.99/axle$149.99–$249.99/axlePep Boys by $25
Oil change
Conventional oil change$44.99–$64.99$39.99–$54.99Pep Boys by $7.50
Synthetic blend oil change$59.99–$79.99$54.99–$74.99Pep Boys by $5
High-mileage oil change$69.99–$89.99$64.99–$84.99Pep Boys by $5
Full synthetic oil change$79.99–$109.99$74.99–$99.99Pep Boys by $7.50
Wheel alignment
Wheel alignment (standard)$89.99–$129.99$89.99–$129.99About the same
Tire rotation
Tire rotation$19.99–$29.99$19.99–$29.99About the same
Tire installation
Installation per tire (mount & balance)$19.99–$29.99/tire$19.99–$29.99/tireAbout the same

Typical prices at most U.S. locations, compared at the middle of each range. Differences under 2% count as “about the same”.

How Midas and Pep Boys differ

Midas

  • Lifetime guarantee on brake pads and shoes (labor not included).
  • Almost all shops are franchised; prices vary by owner.
  • Started as an exhaust specialist in 1956.
  • Free brake inspections.

Discounts: shop coupons and free inspections.

All Midas prices →

Pep Boys

  • Company-run service chain owned by Icahn Automotive.
  • Stopped selling auto parts in 2024 to focus on service.
  • Full repair shop: tires, brakes, alignments, A/C and diagnostics.
  • Online booking and coupons for every location.

Discounts: online coupons, Pep Boys Rewards and fleet.

All Pep Boys prices →

Midas vs. Pep Boys: FAQ

Is Midas cheaper than Pep Boys?

Pep Boys is cheaper for 5 of the 8 services both chains price (3 cost about the same). The biggest gap is conventional oil change: $44.99–$64.99 at Midas versus $39.99–$54.99 at Pep Boys. Both chains set prices by market, so compare the two locations near you before you book.

Which is cheaper for a brake pad replacement, Midas or Pep Boys?

Pep Boys is cheaper: $149.99–$299.99 at Midas versus $149.99–$249.99 at Pep Boys for brake pads, one axle.

Which is cheaper for an oil change, Midas or Pep Boys?

Pep Boys is cheaper: $79.99–$109.99 at Midas versus $74.99–$99.99 at Pep Boys for full synthetic oil change.

Which is cheaper for a wheel alignment, Midas or Pep Boys?

They cost about the same: $89.99–$129.99 at Midas and $89.99–$129.99 at Pep Boys.

Which is cheaper for a tire rotation, Midas or Pep Boys?

They cost about the same: $19.99–$29.99 at Midas and $19.99–$29.99 at Pep Boys.

Which is cheaper for a tire installation, Midas or Pep Boys?

They cost about the same: $19.99–$29.99 at Midas and $19.99–$29.99 at Pep Boys.

More comparisons

Firestone Complete Auto Care vs. Pep BoysFirestone Complete Auto Care vs. MidasJiffy Lube vs. MidasPep Boys vs. Valvoline Instant Oil Change