Costco vs. Discount Tire: prices compared 2026

Discount Tire is cheaper for 1 of the 2 services both chains price (1 cost about the same). The biggest gap is installation per tire (mount & balance): $24.99 at Costco versus Free at Discount Tire.

Prices checked

Price comparison

ServiceCostcoDiscount TireCheaper
Tire installation
Installation per tire (mount & balance)$24.99/tireFreeDiscount Tire by $24.99
Tire rotation
Tire rotationFreeFreeAbout the same

Typical prices at most U.S. locations, compared at the middle of each range. Differences under 2% count as “about the same”.

How Costco and Discount Tire differ

Costco

  • Membership fee: $65 or $130 (since September 2024).
  • Tire installation package includes lifetime rotations and road-hazard coverage.
  • Eye exams by independent optometrists.

Discounts: executive reward, Costco Anywhere Visa and tire promotions.

All Costco prices →

Discount Tire

  • Tires and wheels only — no oil changes, brakes or alignments.
  • Free flat repairs for any tire, wherever you bought it.
  • Installation included with tires bought there.
  • Called America’s Tire in much of California.

Discounts: instant and mail-in rebates, price match and Discount Tire credit card.

All Discount Tire prices →

Costco vs. Discount Tire: FAQ

Is Costco cheaper than Discount Tire?

Discount Tire is cheaper for 1 of the 2 services both chains price (1 cost about the same). The biggest gap is installation per tire (mount & balance): $24.99 at Costco versus Free at Discount Tire. Both chains set prices by market, so compare the two locations near you before you book.

Which is cheaper for a tire installation, Costco or Discount Tire?

Discount Tire is cheaper: $24.99 at Costco versus Free at Discount Tire for installation per tire (mount & balance).

Which is cheaper for a tire rotation, Costco or Discount Tire?

They cost about the same: Free at Costco and Free at Discount Tire.

More comparisons

BJ’s Wholesale Club vs. CostcoCostco vs. Sam’s ClubCostco vs. WalmartDiscount Tire vs. WalmartDiscount Tire vs. Firestone Complete Auto CareDiscount Tire vs. Sam’s Club